In the Premier League, a high-risk and high-attention world, excellent players are the basic requirement

In the high-risk and high-attention world of the Premier League, excellent players are the basic requirement, but there is also a dark side, that is, those players who have been hyped up and have a reputation but have not met the expectations of fans.

These players are often more famous than their actual influence, and their performances are analyzed and praised, but they have made very few lasting contributions on the court.

Although there are many different opinions on who is overrated, AI has selected the five most overrated players in history based on data-driven development, and attached a detailed explanation.

5. Harry Maguire (Leicester City, Manchester United)

Although Maguire was the most expensive defender in the world when Manchester United signed him from Leicester City with a record £80 million of defender transfer fees in 2019, he has always struggled to match his worth. He is often criticized for his slow movements, clumsy, and constant mistakes at critical moments when making calm decisions, and Maguire's performance at the club level is far less than he did at the England national team.

Solskjaer briefly awarded him the captain's armband, but under the subsequent head coach Tenhamag, he quickly lost his captain position. Although he can occasionally score key goals and show his fighting spirit, the high transfer fee has always been a huge shadow of his reputation.

4. Robinho (Manchester City)

Robinho, who was in the halo of "New Bailey", joined Manchester City in 2008 with a record £32.5 million. Although his early performance flashed with skills and aura, his overall contribution declined rapidly. He scored 14 goals in his first Premier League season, but his form quickly disappeared, especially in the away game, where commentators and coaches pointed out his lack of effort.

Off-field distraction, absence of training and conflicts with managers have further damaged his image. After 53 appearances and 16 goals and 13 assists, Robinho left Manchester City, marking one of the last few major mistakes before rising to become the Premier League overlord.

3. Wilhel (Arsenal, West Ham United, Bournemouth)

Wilhel is often listed as one of the most overrated players in Premier League history. Even Roy Keane once bluntly stated that he was "the most overrated player on earth" after seeing his disappointing Europa League performance.

Although he has been praised for his dribbling ability and technical skills, and some even compared him to Messi, injuries and instability have prevented Wilhel from fulfilling his potential. Repeated setbacks and failure to maintain the elite level expected from his early potential have seriously affected his career.

2. Ali (Tottenham, Everton)

Ali emerged from Tottenham. With his participation in 44 goals (goals + assists) in his first 70 Premier League games, he quickly became one of the most dazzling young stars in the league. He also secured his position in England's national team, playing every game of the 2018 World Cup.

However, after its rapid rise, Alibaba suffered a sharp recession due to injuries, off-court problems and a decline in form. His career ended up in a serious stagnation after Tottenham lost his position and moved to Everton. After a recent transfer to Cuomo, he was sent off with a red card in his debut. At the age of 29, many people are wondering whether he can regain his former edge.

1. Pogba (Manchester United)

When Pogba returned to Manchester United in 2016 for £89 million, he was expected to be a transformative figure in clubs and even English football. After Juventus shines with its versatility and talent, Pogba seems destined to achieve something great.

However, unstable form, injuries, disputes with management and repeated demands to leave the team have ruined his Old Trafford career. Although there are occasional highlights, he rarely continues to deliver the outstanding performance people expect, and eventually becomes a symbolic figure in Manchester United's struggle after Ferguson retires. After six years of playing for the club, Pogba failed to prove his high value and eventually left the team as a free agent.